An iron ore trader and the invoices nobody checked
Two fraud allegations in a week, in unrelated markets, share one feature: collateral verified by paperwork that nobody independently checked.
Singapore's police force confirmed on Thursday that it has begun looking into Radiant World, the iron ore trader that has been under pressure for weeks as counterparties and creditors stepped back over concerns about allegedly falsified documents. Vitol and Cargill stopped trading with the firm at the end of July. The US Justice Department and the CFTC are examining transactions around it, and the UK's Financial Conduct Authority is monitoring developments. Radiant World has not been accused of wrongdoing. The plumbing here is worth understanding because it is unglamorous and enormous. Commodity trade finance is short-term lending secured against paper: an invoice, a bill of lading, a warehouse receipt. The bank does not go and look at the ore. It looks at the documents, lends against them for sixty or ninety days, and gets repaid when the cargo sells. The whole system runs on the assumption that a document represents one cargo, once. If that assumption fails — if invoices are duplicated or fabricated — two lenders can end up holding claims on the same pile of ore, or one lender on no ore at all. This is the same structural failure the SEC alleged this week at Tricolor, whose former CEO and two colleagues are accused of double-pledging hundreds of millions of dollars of subprime auto loans across more than $1.9bn of asset-backed offerings. What we do not know is which banks are exposed or for how much. What is notable is the sequence: creditors withdrew before any regulator arrived. That is market discipline working faster than enforcement, which is the good version. It also means a funding withdrawal is already in progress, which is why this moves ignition and not just fragility.