A Korean share sale that was 400 times oversubscribed lost a third of its value in one day
If the public will not buy shares in these AI data-center companies at any price, the debt funding the boom has no cushion of shareholders' money coming in behind it.
Elice, a Seoul company that rents out computing power for AI, fell as much as 38% in its first session on Korea's second-tier stock exchange on Tuesday and closed down 32%, the worst opening day for a sizable Korean stock-market debut in Bloomberg's records. The first day is supposed to be the easy part, and this sale was priced as if it would be. The company raised 201bn won ($151m) at 90,500 won a share, the top of its range, with the slice set aside for ordinary savers subscribed 400 times over. It closed at 61,500 won (Bloomberg).
On Monday we noted the trillions of won of savers' money chasing this sale in the week the AI trade broke. This is what that money bought. When a sale is 400 times oversubscribed, almost everyone who applied got a sliver and most of the cash went back, so the loss falls on the few shares actually handed out, and the real signal is about the buyer who never turned up. Demand at that scale was demand for a first-day jump, not for a share of a data-center operator founded in 2015 by three KAIST doctoral students as a coding-education platform. When the jump did not come, there was no second buyer.
That matters beyond Korea because selling shares to the public was the exit the whole trade was built on. The plan was that money raised from public shareholders would carry the debt that pays for the building. Bloomberg lists the rest of the queue: Firmus scrapped its listing, AirTrunk is delaying, Nscale faces pushback on the value it wants, and CoreWeave has more than halved since May with its bonds trading as if it might not pay. Each door that closes pushes the next company further into the hands of the private lenders and the equipment suppliers extending credit, who were already there. On the meter this is tinder, not a spark: a buyer the boom was counting on has left.
The one consolation is small. Goldman's desk that lends to hedge funds says they cut technology shares at the fastest pace in its records in the five sessions to October 15, and the borrowed money behind their bets is at a one-year low (Bloomberg). The sellers using borrowed money may have mostly sold. Korea's savers, it turns out, were on the other side of them.