France pays 5% to borrow while US government bonds become the refuge
The rate shock has turned around: investors are buying US government bonds for safety again, and the strain has moved to a major European government that cannot print the currency it owes.
France's government paid more than 5% to borrow for ten years on Thursday morning, the most since 2002 (the ten-year rate reached 5.0601%), and the extra France pays compared with Germany reached its widest since 2011 (1.64 percentage points, per LSEG data cited by the Wall Street Journal). Germany's borrowing cost went the other way, down 0.017 points to 3.407%. So did America's: the interest rate the US government pays to borrow for ten years fell 0.059 points to 5.088% during European trading, and the rate for thirty years hit a four-week low of 5.376%. By the time we built this edition the US ten-year rate was 5.04%.
Read those three moves together. France, Germany and the United States borrow in the same world, and this morning investors sold one of them to buy the other two. "Today's tentative risk-off, with U.S. Treasurys supported and struggling equities, argues for continued pressure on eurozone government bond spreads," Commerzbank's Hauke Siemssen wrote. In other words, when investors sell anything risky and buy American government bonds instead, the weaker European governments are the ones left paying more. The Journal attributes the rush into US bonds to falling stock prices and "concerns about the sustainability of debt-funded investments in artificial intelligence infrastructure", and notes that worries about growth now outweigh worries about inflation.
That is the mechanism. For most of October the story was a rate shock: US government bonds sold off, and everything priced from them repriced. Today those bonds are the refuge, and the pressure has moved to the one large borrower that cannot print the currency it owes. The gap over Germany is what investors demand for lending to France rather than Germany in the same euro; at 1.64 percentage points they are demanding more than at any time since the euro crisis, and the Journal names budget worries and social unrest as the reasons.
What it does not yet show is anything breaking. The Journal reports no failed auction, and no sign that French banks or insurers, the natural owners of French government bonds, are being forced to sell. But a major government paying 5% raises the cost of every French mortgage and company loan priced from it, and the rush into US bonds happened because investors fear the AI boom, not because they stopped fearing American debt. Yesterday we recorded the French gap above 1.5 percentage points for the first time since 2012. Today it is 1.64. That is a step, not a repeat, and it is ignition: nothing new was stacked on the pile, but a spark in a core European bond market got closer.