Nobody would buy $3bn of bonds meant to pay for Alphabet's electricity
Alphabet is the strongest borrower among the giant cloud companies. If the money for its power is being repriced by bond buyers who never thought of themselves as lenders to the AI boom, the cost of the whole build-out just went up.
Goldman Sachs has shelved two bond deals, worth $3bn between them, that would have put long-term money into Alphabet's hands to pay for electricity, after buyers refused to take them at the price on offer, Bloomberg reported on Thursday afternoon. The bonds coming due in 2039 were being talked at an interest rate of 5.15%, about 1.38 percentage points more than the safest city and state bonds pay (138 basis points, in the source's terms). On November 4 Alphabet was the recipient on a $1.6bn deal of the same kind, and the slice due in 2040 cost it only 1.11 percentage points over that benchmark (111bp). Two weeks later the market wanted roughly a quarter more on top, and even then did not turn up in size. Deals get repriced all the time. A deal for a borrower of this quality being pulled for lack of buyers is not routine.
The structure, in general terms, works like this. A public utility or gas authority sells bonds that are exempt from tax, and hands the money upfront to an energy supplier in exchange for years of power. The company on the receiving end gets twenty-year money at the cheap rates that tax-free municipal bonds command. The Bloomberg piece does not spell out the terms of these particular deals, and we are not going to guess at them. What it does say is who is borrowing, in effect, and that the buyers said no for now.
Two things make this the most telling fact of the day. First, the borrower. Alphabet has the strongest balance sheet, the list of what it owns and owes, of any of the giant cloud companies. If its power money is being repriced, then the smaller firms that rent out computing power, whose bonds have already been paying investors more than 15%, have a problem bigger than their own names. Second, the lender. Funds that buy municipal bonds do not think of themselves as financing electricity for data centers. That is exactly the kind of unlabeled, untested channel our running argument says this build-out has migrated into, and it turns out the people in that channel care about price. Shannon Rinehart of Columbia Threadneedle put it plainly: "some investors were looking for a spread that just didn't match up." In other words, the extra interest on offer was not enough for the risk they saw.
This is a postponement, not a failure. Both deals are "still moving forward", and Andy Hobbs of Allspring expects them to get done after the holiday with demand "relatively strong". Last week QTS, a data center operator owned by Blackstone, managed to sell $300m of an $800m bond; this week a far better borrower chose to wait rather than pay up. Alphabet's shares fell 3.5% on the day and are 16% lower over the last 20 trading sessions. For the odds of a crash this is fragility, not a spark: nothing broke, but the price of money for the strongest name in the build-out just moved, and the extra interest the market demands when these deals come back is the number to watch.