The stand-ins lose their job: Taiwan's worst week since 1991
The listing swapped a private valuation that could only go up for a public share price that can fall, and the chip stocks that stood in for it are being sold by investors shrinking every bet they have, not by investors who changed their minds.
Taiwan's Taiex fell 6.2% on Friday to close its worst week since 1991. South Korea's Kospi is heading for an 8% weekly loss and Japan's Nikkei 225 is back where it stood in April. These are not ordinary bad days; a 6% fall in a major market happens a handful of times in a decade. The trigger was not a bad result or a new export rule. It was Anthropic, whose shares slid in after-hours trading on Thursday after closing their first session 17% up, and whose listing was the event the entire chip supply chain had been waiting for (Bloomberg).
The mechanism is worth saying plainly. For two years the only way to own Anthropic was to own the companies that sell to it: TSMC, SK Hynix, Samsung and the rest of the chain. Those stocks were worth extra because the thing itself could not be bought, and every private funding round valued Anthropic higher without anyone being able to sell. Thursday ended that. There is now $107bn of Anthropic stock that trades every afternoon and can go down, and a public price that need not agree with the private one. The stand-ins lose their reason to exist at the moment the real thing becomes available.
What is being sold is a position more than an opinion. Bank of America's Winnie Wu called it 'a painful unwind, and everyone is trying to de-risk, de-gross,' adding that 'it feels like there's no buyers out there.' In other words, hedge funds, the investment firms that bet in ways ordinary funds cannot, are cutting both their bets on prices rising and their bets on prices falling at the same time, and that kind of selling does not care that Nvidia beat expectations on Tuesday. Reed Capital's Gerald Gan said Anthropic's debut had suffered 'the same predicament as SpaceX', undermining 'what I had considered the final pillar supporting the AI rally'.
American markets have not yet done what Asia's have. The S&P is 8.6% below its October 6 high and the Nasdaq 100 is 13.5% below, and the Nasdaq 100's worst ten-day fall is 8.4%. The VIX at 29.7 is the highest of this run. The gap between a 6% day in Taipei and a 2% day in New York is the gap between where the chips are made and where the debt was sold, and it closes in one direction or the other.