Half out, at a lower price
Limiting withdrawals two quarters in a row at the largest fund of its kind means the line of people trying to leave is a fixture rather than a one-quarter scare, and everyone in that line is being paid at a valuation that keeps slipping.
Blackstone Private Credit Fund, known as BCRED, told shareholders on Thursday that it would give money back to only half of those who asked for it. Holders of 10% of the fund's shares wanted out; the fund is paying 5%, the second quarter in a row it has capped withdrawals at that level. At $77bn it is the largest fund of its type that does not trade on an exchange: it borrows money, lends it to mid-sized private companies, and passes the interest to shareholders. Funds have quarters in which some investors leave. A tenth of the shareholders trying to leave at once, twice running, is not that. Bloomberg reports that anyone who lined up over the last two quarters will have got about 75% of their money out within roughly 90 days. The price the fund says its holdings are worth has fallen since January (from $24.68 a share at the end of January to $23.64 at the end of July, a 4.2% decline), and this quarter's payout will be set at whatever that figure is at the end of September (Bloomberg). The mechanics matter more than the headline. The fund holds loans that cannot easily be sold. The manager decides what those loans are worth, and investors can leave only through a once-a-quarter window capped at about 5% of the fund's value. Shutting that window is not a malfunction. It is the design. What the design does is turn a request to leave into a bet on a future valuation. If you asked to leave in July and are paid in October at the end-of-September figure, you carry three more months of the manager's valuations, and those valuations have been falling. BCRED says it is "well capitalized" and that loan repayments and new money coming in have outpaced the money it has handed back. It also points to returns of 9% a year since it started, nearly 3 points more than loans to heavily indebted companies have paid over the same stretch. Both may be true, and neither answers the question the queue is asking, which is what the loans would fetch if they had to be sold. The only real sale prices we have seen for this kind of paper came from a $90m offer to buy shares in five similar funds, at an average of 26% below what the funds themselves said they were worth. We covered it earlier this week. That answer is well below the fund's. Investors in funds that do trade on exchanges see it differently. Ares Capital, a similar lender with a listed share price, is 0.9% below its high, and Blackstone Secured Lending is 1.4% below its high. Blackstone itself, the manager, is down 4.2% o