The Treasury is buying $4bn of its own bonds a session. It is not enough.
A program announced to hold down the government's long-term borrowing costs has now run for two days. Those costs rose on both, which tells you the government is not the one setting the price.
The US government's borrowing costs rose for a second straight day this morning and now sit above every level in our last eight readings (the ten-year rate at 4.92%, the thirty-year at 5.35%). This is the second day of a Treasury program announced specifically to stop that from happening. A government stepping into its own bond market to push down what it pays, and losing on both days it tried, is not routine, and it tells you who actually sets the price. The program itself: on August 19 the Treasury Department, which borrows the money the government spends, said it would double its buybacks of bonds coming due in ten to thirty years, from $2bn to at least $4bn per operation, running from September 9 to November 4. One tally puts September's total at about $38bn (sweep). The Treasury buys old long-term bonds from the dealers who hold them and pays for them by selling new IOUs that come due in weeks. The market ends up holding less of the debt whose price falls badly when rates rise, and more of the kind that barely notices. Bessent, who runs the Treasury, has called it a 'Treasury Twist'. The twenty- and thirty-year rates fell sharply when it was announced in August. They have risen since the buying actually began. Why might $4bn a session fail to move a $28tn market? Because the people who set the price at the margin are not the Treasury. Hedge funds are financing about $3tn of government bond holdings with cash borrowed overnight against bonds put up as security, and roughly $830bn of that is one trade: borrowing heavily to profit from a small gap between two nearly identical prices (Reuters). Japan sold down $88bn of foreign securities in August to pay for a record defense of the yen. One ally's monthly selling was twice the Treasury's entire September buyback. And Waller, one of the Federal Reserve's governors, said on September 3 there is 'no more premium for safe, liquid U.S. government debt'. In other words, investors no longer pay extra to hold it because it is no longer scarce, so the interest rate that neither speeds nor slows the economy is higher than it was (sweep). Two details are worth watching. The five-year rate rose more than the ten-year today, even though the buybacks target the longest bonds, which suggests the market is repricing borrowing at every length rather than reacting to how much long debt is on offer. And gold fell 2.2% over five days while the dollar rose. That is not money fleeing America. It is money demanding more interes