Change the assumptions and a tenth of a fund disappears
Large private lending funds have been forced to cut their values and freeze withdrawals before in this cycle, but always by a queue of investors wanting their money back. This is the first time an auditor has done it, and the price the funds actually trade at says the auditor did not go far enough.
Metrics Credit Partners, an Australian firm that manages about A$40bn of loans to companies, halted trading in three of its funds listed on the Australian stock exchange before trading began on Monday and cut the values it says those funds are worth. It did so because its auditor, KPMG, made "different decisions" about the assumptions and probability weightings behind those values. The measure that falls is net tangible assets, what each fund holds minus what it owes: down 12.16% at the Metrics Real Estate Multi-Strategy Fund, 10.08% at the Metrics Income Opportunities Trust and 1.99% at the Metrics Master Income Trust (Reuters). Funds revise their values all the time. An auditor knocking a tenth off one over a weekend is not that.
Read the middle number. A loan that has never been sold on a market does not have a price. It has a set of assumptions: will the borrower pay, when, and how much comes back if not. Each carries a probability the manager assigns. Change those weightings and a tenth of a fund disappears without a single borrower missing a payment. Nothing in the portfolio changed over the weekend. The person holding the pen did.
The most telling figure is what buyers already thought. The real-estate fund's units last changed hands at A$1.68 while the fund said they were worth A$2.53, a discount of 34%. Even against the new figure of A$2.22, the traded price is 24% lower. People who owned the listed units had been saying for months that the values were too high. The auditor has now agreed with them about a third of the way. Metrics says it lent nothing to Bathla, the property developer that collapsed last month owing A$3bn to some 40 lenders, and Australia's financial regulator warned the whole sector about unrealistic valuations only last week.
Hours later, on the other side of the world, staff at the SEC, the agency that polices American markets, put out what they called a "critical reminder" about valuing assets that do not trade, urging "particular care" for private lending funds because their loans have no ready quoted price. It contains no new rule. It does record that at midyear more than $14.5bn of investors' money was stuck in more than a dozen private lending funds that had stopped paying it back (Bloomberg).
Metrics is the visible version of this. Its funds are listed, so the gap between what the manager said and what buyers would pay sat on a screen for anyone to see. The same kind of assumptions sit in funds nobody can trade, on insurers' balance sheets (the lists of what they own and owe) and in retirement accounts, where no auditor has yet said no. For the meter this is the discovery kind: the world did not get more dangerous on Monday. Our measure of how much of the pile is overvalued got better.