Hedge funds are being told to get out of French government bonds
The first named forced selling of this bond rout happened in the government debt of a major economy, and the sellers were funds using borrowed money, not the long-term holders whose exit would be the next, worse stage.
Interest rates on short-dated French government debt swung by as much as 0.4 of a percentage point over Thursday and Friday, among the largest moves in years, as hedge funds that had borrowed to own French bonds were forced to sell. In a market that size, a move like that in two days is not a bad week; it is the sound of positions being closed under orders. "It's been a slow bleed until this week," said Hank Calenti of SMBC, "which suggests people were starting to get tapped on the shoulder by risk managers and told it's time to vacate" (Wall Street Journal). In other words, the funds did not change their minds; the people who police their losses made them sell.
The trade is simple. Borrow cheaply and short-term, either as cash borrowed overnight against bonds put up as security or in yen, buy French bonds that pay a little more interest than German ones, and use borrowed money to make that small difference several times bigger. France was the preferred venue because its €3.5tn market, Europe's largest, is deep enough to get in and out of in size. The weakness is that the bet is sized to how calm prices are. A fund's risk limit shrinks when prices start to move, so the position must be cut whether or not the manager still believes in it. The cut moves prices, which shrinks the next fund's limit. The Journal describes "a self-fueling bout of losses and selling", and Pimco's Konstantin Veit says plainly that hedge funds are closing out these borrow-cheap-lend-dear trades "of which France has been part".
Who is left holding the bonds matters. More than half of French government debt, $3.9tn, is owned by foreigners, according to MUFG. The Japanese buyers who filled that order book for a decade can now earn comparable interest at home or on German bonds, and a week ago one large Japanese manager said it had sold every French bond it owned. On Thursday the gap between what Italy and Germany pay to borrow for two years doubled, as the stress moved south.
French shares and the euro rose on Friday, and the European Central Bank stands behind the eurozone's bond market as a last resort. But a forced seller in the government bond market of one of the seven largest economies is the thing this site watches for, and this week one appeared with its machinery visible: borrowed money, not anyone's judgment, set the price of French debt. That is ignition. Nothing was added to the pile; the spark got closer.