A buyout loan loses 11 cents on the dollar before the buyout even closes
A loan that loses 11 cents on the dollar within weeks of being sold is a live test of whether the loans behind this year's buyouts were judged honestly, and whether they can survive a shopper who has stopped spending.
In September, Bank of America sold investors a loan of more than $1bn to pay for Intersnack's $2.9bn purchase of the potato-chip maker Utz, at 99 cents on the dollar. It is now quoted at about 88 cents, according to Bloomberg, which makes it one of the worst-performing loan deals of the year, and the purchase has not even closed yet (Bloomberg). Loans like this are meant to sit near their sale price for years. One that loses 11 cents in two months, before the money has even changed hands, means somebody got the company badly wrong.
The trigger was Utz's third-quarter results on November 6. Its profit, on the measure lenders use (adjusted EBITDA, which strips out interest, tax and some accounting charges), fell more than 30%. The company blamed higher supply-chain costs and, in the chief executive's words, consumer weakness amid inflation. Buyers say that in September, while the loan was being sold, management stood by its forecast and said nothing about a drop of that size. They are now demanding answers from Utz and from Bank of America, which arranged the deal, and the bank has been organizing meetings with selected holders this week.
The mechanism matters more than the snack. A loan like this is sized off that profit figure; the debt is set as a multiple of it. If profit falls 30%, a company that owed five years of profit now owes seven, and nothing else has changed. The buyers of this kind of loan are typically funds that bundle loans together and sell slices of the income to investors (CLOs) and loan funds, though Bloomberg does not name them. They paid 99 and are carrying an 11-point loss, roughly $110m on the loan's face value, on something they were told was stable eight weeks ago.
It fits a pattern we counted on Monday, when JPMorgan's banks were offering Qualtrics debt near 85 cents and Fullscript's $1.3bn loan failed to find buyers. Those were loans the market refused. Utz is worse. The market accepted it, and then the borrower's own numbers made the acceptance look like a mistake. Whether the arranger misjudged or was misled is exactly what the holders want to know, and either answer makes the next loan sale harder.
This is the third kind of story, the kind where nothing got more dangerous and our measurement improved. No new debt was created this week; a price everyone agreed on in September was tested and failed. That is the pile becoming visible rather than taller, so we have not moved fragility on it. But if the next few loan sales go the way of Qualtrics and Fullscript, the buyer for this kind of paper will have left, and that is when it starts counting.